is there anything more delicious than nutella? probably not. when i ran across this recipe on erins food files a few weeks ago, i knew i needed an excuse to make them as soon as possible. with a cookie swap party to attend this past sunday, + valentine’s day yesterday, it seemed like the perfect time to whip up a dozen (or three dozen in my case, most of which have already been eaten).
these cookies are insanely delicious. i’m not huge on sweets, but i ate three within an hour of making them. honey put back 4 of ’em (really) in about ten minutes. a few things to note – they look crispy in these pictures, but they aren’t. instead, they’re wonderfully chewy, exactly how i like cookies to be. also, in the midst of making them, i discovered i was out of both frangelico + vanilla extract (the horror!), so in a moment of creativity, i substituted godiva chocolate liqueur which was a perfect substitute.
i’m so happy i stumbled across this recipe + even happier now that i’ve successfully made them. this cookie recipe is definitely a keeper – give ’em a try!
nutella cookies
makes about 3 dozen cookies, adapted from culinary concoctions by peabody, as seen on erins food files
ingredients
½ cup unsalted butter, at room temperature
½ cup granulated sugar
½ cup firmly packed light brown sugar
½ cup nutella
1 egg
½ tsp. frangelico or vanilla extract
1 ½ cups flour
1 tsp. baking soda
¼ tsp. salt
1/3 cup mini chocolate chipsdirections
preheat oven to 350 degrees.
cream butter with an electric mixer about 1 minute until smooth. add in both sugars. beat on high speed about 3 minutes until light + fluffy, scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed.
with the mixer on low, add the egg + frangelico (or vanilla). then add the Nutella + mix well.in a small bowl whisk together the flour, baking soda, + salt. add dry ingredients to wet ingredients, + mix on low speed until incorporated. increase the speed to medium + mix just until the dough is smooth. fold in chocolate chips.
using a small ice cream scoop (or a teaspoon) form the dough into balls + place on greased cookie sheet.
bake 6-7 minutes. let cookies cool about 5 minutes + transfer to a rack to cool completely.
print this recipe
{ 22 comments… read them below or add one }
Oh wow, these look amazing! I’ll be making these asap. Thanks for the recipe!
let me know how they turn out + enjoy ’em!
Your cookies look perfect! YUM! And Godiva liqueur! Wow… Great substitute!
ha, thanks! i gave myself a high five on the godiva substitute, too. =)
You can’t go wrong with Nutella. I can’t wait to make these + share them with hubby + the kiddos. I know they’ll be a huge hit!
i hope they are a big success – let me know how they turn out!
I can personally say that these cookies are delicious…and the extras from the cookie party are still delicious a week later!!!! LOVE these (and to think I’d never had nutella)!
woohoo! i’m so glad you were able to try ’em in person (+ that i was able to see you). =) i’ve already made 5 dozen more since the cookie party. crazy! they’ve been super popular!
oh wow!! I LOVE nutella!! I thought it couldn’t get much better than the amazing nutella/banana combo ice cream that the Piped Piper Creamery has or the nutella custard pie from Foxy Baking Co., but now I must bake these!!!!
you’re going to love them! they’re on extremely high cookie rotation here. =) the great thing is that i almost always have all of the ingredients in the house to make ’em, so i can whip up a batch on the spot whenever i’m craving a little nutella sweet.
My hubby will love these! I can’t wait to try them out!
i can personally attest that these are a huge hit with husbands of all kinds. i’m sure yours will love ’em, too! let me know how they turn out for you!
I’m so happy you reposted this today — having a nutella craving! my brother’s favorite thing of all time is nutella & he’s visiting in a few weeks. I think I Must make some of these!
Thanks Amy
your nutella-lovin’ brother is going to be thrilled with these. can’t wait to hear how it goes! =)
I can smell them. they look amazing!
A) yum B) great photos C) Thanks for introducing me to Erin’s Foodie Files! Love her blog and adding it to my reader.
you are so welcome! erin rocks + i’m lucky to know her in real life. her blog, recipes + pics are just amazing. so glad i could introduce you to her!
I made these cookies yesterday (with just the vanilla) and they were a huge hit. There are only a couple left. Definitely going to be making them again!! Thanks!
yay! so glad you liked ’em! they are definitely my go-to cookie recipe + always a crowd pleaser. you can’t go wrong with nutella! =)
Absolutely fantastic! I used vanilla extract because it’s what I had around — but your last minute substitution of Godiva liqueur sounds devine, and I will likely use that next time
so glad they turned out fabulous for you! aren’t they just the yummiest things? + pretty easy to make, too, which is always a nice plus. =)
Ohhhh, hello! Be still my heart…Nutella makes me swoon!
{ 1 trackback }